February 17, 2020

Happy Presidents’ Day! This is a day when Americans celebrate all Presidents, but in a larger sense, we celebrate the system by which we pick our national leader. The Founders devised a brilliant system that gave a say to all the individual states, with their vastly different cultures and interests. We also celebrate our unprecedented history of respecting the vote of the people and the peaceful transfer of power. It’s too bad that many people now are so eager to trash the Electoral system, disrespect the voters’ choice and resist the peaceful transfer of power in the name of preserving their own political power. But they can at least pretend to respect those traditions for one day, then go back to observing “NOT My President Day” the other 364 days of the year (or 365 in leap years like this.)

I wrote an essay about Presidents’ Day in 2018, and I think it bears repeating, since nothing really has changed since it first appeared…

Monday was Presidents Day, and this year brought sobering new evidence that not only are Americans sadly ignorant of US history, but our historians aren’t exactly setting the woods on fire in that department, either.

A number of polls were released, asking the public to rank the greatest Presidents of all time. Overall, the highest vote-getters were John Kennedy, Barack Obama and Ronald Reagan. JFK had some major accomplishments, like the space program, but his term was tragically cut short after less than three years. Obama’s #1 ranking is similar to those Internet lists of the “all-time greatest movies” that include nothing made before 1995 (“Wow, ‘The Last Jedi’ is #1!”) They’re more a testament to the youthful ignorance of the rankers than the quality of the films. And while I take a back seat to nobody in my admiration for Reagan’s accomplishments, even he would likely protest that Washington and Lincoln should have been on top.

I don’t think most people these days appreciate the unprecedented service Washington performed by refusing to rule as a king and voluntarily stepping down from power to rejoin the people. Without his example, the presidency might not even be recognizable today. Well, at least George and Abe made the top 10 in most polls, but I suspect it’s less because of their historical significance than the fact that young people know them from the money. We’re lucky they didn’t name Alexander Hamilton as the best President, because he’s on the $10 bill and he starred in that rap musical.

But it’s easy to pick on the choices of the general public, who will naturally name things that are most recent and fresh in their minds. But what excuses do alleged experts have for their biased and uninformed choices? For instance, the 2018 Presidents & Executive Politics Presidential Greatness Survey is based on responses from current and recent members of the Presidents & Executive Politics Section of the American Political Science Association. They ranked Lincoln #1 and Washington #2. Their top 10 also includes Thomas Jefferson, Teddy Roosevelt and FDR. But LBJ at #10? (I get it: they love big government). Reagan only made it to #9, and at #8: Barack Obama (it goes without saying that they ranked Trump dead last, despite him presiding over the destruction of ISIS, a tax cut that’s firing up the economy and the rollback of executive overreach, all in his first year -- yet he’s ranked lower than William Henry Harrison, who died of pneumonia 31 days after being sworn in. He must’ve had one heck of a month.)

I think all you need to know about the “expertise” (or the bias) of these particular Presidential experts is that their top 10 includes Obama but not, say, James K. Polk. Polk oversaw the winning of the Mexican-American War; the reestablishing of the independent Treasury system; the annexation of Texas; the Oregon Treaty that set the border with Canada and won more of Oregon from the British than anyone expected; and the Mexican Cession, which added territory that included the current states of California, Nevada and Utah, most of Arizona, half of New Mexico, and some pretty sizable chunks of Colorado and Wyoming. He even tried to buy Cuba, which would have prevented a lot of grief down the road, but Spain wouldn’t sell. And Polk did all that and more in just four years because he kept his promise to serve only one term. For that alone, he deserves to be in the top 10 (They rank Polk at #20, seven places below Bill Clinton).

In comparison, Obama’s eight years gave us…Obamacare? A record stretch of low GDP growth? The spread of ISIS? Michelle’s school lunch program?

I can’t help wondering how many of these alleged “presidential history experts” who lionize Obama live in states that wouldn’t even be part of America if it weren’t for James K. Polk.

Leave a Comment

Note: Fields marked with an * are required.

Your Information
Your Comment
BBML accepted!

Comments 1-1 of 1

  • Mark Nolan Johnson

    06/22/2020 01:14 AM

    I thought it a challenge to do my own rating of U.S. presidents, so I ratcheted up the task by summarizing what I feel were each president's most outstanding achievement(s) in one sentence. Here are my 15 top presidents, and I'll send you 2nd and 3rd batches if you're interested:
    1. Abraham Lincoln printed a debt-free currency, the “greenback”, and got passed a nationally regulated private banking system intent on issuing cheap credit
    2. George Washington his farewell address warned the nation to be ever wary of perpetually favoring or making an enemy out of any foreign nation
    3. Thomas Jefferson his radical “all men are created equal” premise set the nation’s ideal, and the hard climb to that ideal is what is now taking shape as a national purpose
    4. Andrew Jackson led a successful drive to de-charter the 2nd Bank of the United States, allowing the new nation to break free, for a time, of odious foreign financial domination
    5. James Madison at the Constitutional Convention he “shifted the debate toward a compromise of ‘shared sovereignty’ between the national and state governments”
    6. John Adams carefully steered the U.S. to build up an Army and Navy to deter France during the Quasi-War all while keeping a check on a dangerously ambitious Hamilton
    7. James Monroe forced Spain to give up Florida, helped negotiate the Louisiana Purchase, and declared U.S. opposition to any new or recolonization in the Americas
    8. Ulysses S. Grant his magnanimous prior treatment of defeated Confederate soldiers set the stage for Reconstruction, and replanted the seeds of “all men are created equal”
    9. Franklin D. Roosevelt foresaw the need for older citizens to retire with financial dignity and withstood all criticism to push through the Social Security Act
    10. John F. Kennedy authorized the printing of United States Notes as bona fide currency, effectively, but temporarily, serving notice on the Federal Reserve banks the jig was up
    11. Harry S. Truman made the most momentous decision of any president, that of ending the war in the Pacific with the A-bomb, and backed very unpopular civil rights initiatives
    12. Theodore Roosevelt put environmentalism first, establishing the first national parks and spearheaded the availability and control of water in the West
    13. James K. Polk a protégé of Old Hickory, he pushed through the reestablishment of a U.S. Treasury independent of private banks and European banking interests
    14. Dwight D. Eisenhower warned: “we must also be alert to the equal … danger that public policy could itself become the captive of a scientific-technological elite”.
    15. Grover Cleveland supported the reinstatement of Hawaii’s Queen Liliuokalani in 1893 but was later forced by an uncooperative Congress to recognize the Republic of Hawaii
    So let me know if you'd like to read a 2nd batch! Mark Nolan Johnson Culver City, CA 6/21/20