Fake news at Der Spiegel

December 20, 2018

The major German newspaper Der Spiegel revealed that one of its most renowned reporters, Claas Relotius, has been making up news for years.  In a case of journalistic fraud "on a grand scale," Relotius confessed to fabricating parts of at least 14 stories over the years, including an interview with Colin Kaepernick’s parents and a story about a sign on the outskirts of a Minnesota town reading “Keep Mexicans out.”  German media is calling this the biggest media fraud scandal since the Hitler diaries hoax.  Ironically, Relotius won awards for his investigative exposes, including CNN Journalist of the Year in 2014.

Wait, I’m confused: did CNN not know he was making up fake news, or is that what he won the award for?

 

https://www.yahoo.com/news/der-spiegel-says-star-reporter-perpetrated-years-long-134139746.html

I try not to take pleasure in the misfortunes of others, but in the case of the German magazine Der Spiegel’s CNN-award-winning investigative reporter-exposed-as-lying hoax-spinner Claau Rolotius, I’ll make an exception. Not just because his firing after it was discovered that he’d fabricated so many stories over the years was so well-deserved, but because of the way his dishonesty was revealed. 

 

After many years of making up “facts” to fit his preconceived narratives, Rolotius finally tripped up when he – like so many arrogant liberal reporters – slandered and underestimated the intelligence of rural American Trump voters whom he had never really talked to (yes: I did write a book about that very same media failing a year before Trump even announced he was running; thanks for remembering.)

 

In trying to “explain” to European readers how those backward, knuckle-dragging, gun-toting, racist small town yahoos (a stereotype he could have lifted straight out of a 1960s drive-in movie) could have chosen the odious Trump over the resplendent Hillary, Rolotius wrote a profile of Fergus Falls, Minnesota, which voted for Trump by 62.6% (his claim that it was 70% was one of the least glaring of his many falsehoods.) 

 

The intent was obviously to confirm the negative biases held by urban liberal bubble dwellers.  Rolotius put damning quotes into the mouths of people he’d never talked to; invented demeaning descriptions of locals that were wildly inaccurate; created residents who didn’t really exist; made up “facts” out of thin air that a Google search could have debunked (like claiming that “American Sniper” played at the local two-screen theater for two years, when it actually played for one month, and the theater has five screens); and couldn’t even be bothered to get the local topography correct.

 

Rolotius must have figured nobody in Fergus Falls would ever see a European magazine, but he forgot that his low estimation of Trump voters’ intelligence was also just part of his vivid imagination.  The town not only has artists and books and intelligent people, it also has the Internet.  When residents saw to their shock what he had written about them, local blogger Michele Anderson posted a list of just his top 11 lies about Fergus Falls. So I’m happy to note that those maligned small town Americans started the investigations rolling. Rolotius is now gone from Der Spiegel, his name forever associated with journalistic fraud.


Commentary continues below advertisement


Adding more layers to the irony, Anderson is actually a Hillary-voting liberal who works for a local arts group and moved there from Portland, Oregon – but she loves her small town and gets along fine with her neighbors, liberals and conservatives alike.  And Rolotius actually did spend three weeks in Fergus Falls, but either failed (or refused) to learn anything about the town or, more likely, found it didn’t fit his elitist stereotypes so he just made up something that did. 

 

At the link is Anderson’s very entertaining article that blew down Rolotius’ house of cards.  I strongly recommend that it be read by all liberal journalists and politicians who try to avoid thinking too deeply by simply assuming everyone who disagrees with them is a lower species of human. I also recommend that they read my book, “God, Guns, Grits and Gravy.” If they’d done that before the 2016 election, they wouldn’t have been so shocked when Trump won and they wouldn’t have had to tell lies about rural Americans – and Russian collusion – to try to explain it. 

 

https://medium.com/@micheleanderson/der-spiegel-journalist-messed-with-the-wrong-small-town-d92f3e0e01a7

 

 LEAVE ME A COMMENT BY CLICKING HERE.  I READ THEM!

 

More Stories

Electoral College Follow-Up

"Seattle Is Dying"

Congressman Nunes sues Twitter

Comments 1-13 of 13

  • Dusty Hickey

    12/30/2018 09:52 AM

    Gov hope you and your family had a super holiday. I was away and missed many of your articles. WHY? Why do we allow sanctuary cities. I am a citizen and pay taxes why am I not protected. How are these cities in the United States of America allowed to do this? If we need workers after our own citizens are working full board then start a legal program to let in those who are needed not groups that we like here in Georgia give food stamps and use our ER for health care. In an ER guess who pays for this those of us who pay for health care WHY? What else are we to do for humans who need care? So we now have 20 million illegals HOW or WHY? More keep coming. WHY? Traveled into Mexico and seen the poor but where is this our fault. One immigrant here in Georgia about 10 years ago who said he was sending back $800 a month to his family. Said that $24billions was sent back last year. Yet we pay here ? Something smells in the apple barrel.

  • Cathy Cornforth

    12/21/2018 11:29 AM

    Hi Gov. Huckabee,
    I know I'm not in the right article comment area but actually that's my point.
    You've said nothing about the "go fund me page, building the wall".
    Please your thoughts sir.
    Thank you and Merry Christmas to you and your family!
    Cathy, Edmond, OK

  • Anita Mae Barker

    12/20/2018 09:38 PM

    Gets more confusing all the time. Thanks anyhow, Mike.

  • Beth Mulvihill

    12/20/2018 07:40 PM

    Sure CNN knew he was reporting fake news they report alot of fake news too.

  • LLOYD TIEGS

    12/20/2018 06:55 PM

    GOFUNDME was started 3 days ago. In the 3 days he collected $8 million for the wall. Would you consider having him on your T.V, program?

  • Robert Cochran

    12/20/2018 06:35 PM

    After reading your commentaries I can sit back and take a fresh breath. You maintain hope for this country with your southern wit and honesty. Thank you Mike.

  • Stephen Russell

    12/20/2018 05:55 PM

    Maybe the People should elect Judges vs appointments or if so Thier records/ resume made PUBLIC.
    End this judicial activisim since Vietnam War era.
    No More.
    Each judge serves 4 years.

  • Stephen Russell

    12/20/2018 05:32 PM

    Isnt this how OUR Media works ( save FNC, CRTV, Blaze TV, etc)??
    They do fake news since Vietnam War

  • Brigitte Howells

    12/20/2018 03:10 PM

    "Der Spiegel" is a smut sheet and whatever they publish is straight from CNN. But, der Spiegel is not the only publication. I read some of these newspapers and become totally disgusted with what they publish. Their own politics are in a mess. The Germans don't learn either from their history. Same as in the US.

  • Doug proffitt

    12/20/2018 03:02 PM

    Many Thanks!

  • Vivian Richardson

    12/20/2018 02:54 PM

    M so glad this journalist was found out. Speaking of rural and small town people, I was just back in Arkansas at Hope for my Uncles funeral. It was at First Baptist there and he was buried in the Huckabee cemetery and where he livednearby at Evenying Shade area. Is that named after one of your family. I lived in North Little Rock as a teenager and went to Levy Baptist.

  • Grant Carpenter

    12/20/2018 02:52 PM

    This is a sad story. I'm glad the truth came out. But not stories opposing Trump are fake news, true?
    I really appreciate reading your take on the current news. Keep up the good work!

  • TOMMIE CLARK

    12/20/2018 02:40 PM

    i think the whole world has gone crazy IF TRUMP WOULD RELEASE THE DOCUMENTS HE HAS IT MIGHT BRING IN NEW LIGHT TO THE SITUATION. EUROPE NEEDS TO KEEP THEIR NOSE OUT OF OUR BUSINESS.